Greens call for inclusive debate on Constitution
Communiqué de presse du Scottish Green Party, 6 décembre 2007
Green MSP Patrick Harvie criticised both sides of the constitutional question in the Parliamentary debate on a ‘devolution commission’ this morning. He welcomed the opportunity to take forward a debate on Scotland’s future, but regretted that a chance to build the widest possible debate had been missed. The Greens argue that limiting the debate to only one option for constitutional change, whether extending devolution or independence is short-sighted and will not allow for discussion in the round.
Patrick Harvie said « We have heard fine words from both sides about constructive dialogue and mature debate. I regret therefore that the Labour motion, with Tory and Liberal support deliberately avoids being inclusive by attempting to bind the hands of the proposed commission to not allow discussion of independence. The SNP amendment simply restated
their position, and also failed to try to build any broader vision. Whether a conversation or a commission, discussion on the future of Scotland must not be bound by the narrow interests of today’s politicians. »
Mr Harvie added « We need to give the ultimate say on Scotland’s constitutional future to the people of Scotland in a referendum which includes all options. It certainly must not be determined by politicians alone, acting for party interest. Since this motion is proposed by the three main Westminster parties, I think people may question whether this is in fact a Westminster initiative at the behest of the UK party leaders. Any new commission must be free from political control, and a truly Holyrood initiative. »
The Scottish Green MSPs plan to abstain on both the Labour motion and SNP amendment tonight.